In the Beginning
It was the autumn of 2020 when the first seeds of placement excitement were planted. This was gently nurtured and cultivated until it was all consuming. As a student on placement, you get caught up in the hype that you, yourself, have been building for six months prior to placement commencing. You get caught up in the need to deliver the project that you have devised successfully and to deliver it on time. You try to prepare for all eventualities: an ongoing pandemic, staff sick days, missing documentation, and acts of God to name just a few. Despite all this pre-emptive planning, there is one thing you don’t think of – you don’t pre-empt the possibility that your project will be deemed not viable. As a novice not used to the reality of the health information management world and project life, this can be more than a little disconcerting. Yet, if you have the capacity to step back and remove your ego from the situation, it is an incredibly effective learning program, as the Queensland University of Technology (QUT) likes to say, of the real world.
I had spent the build up to my placement planning for a project that centred around the development of a strategy to identify vulnerable patient records – a topic that had been plaguing healthcare providers both public and private for some time. Findings from both the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse (Royal Commission), and Operation Impala conducted by the Crime and Corruption Commission (CCC) found that unauthorised access to patient records and data was a significant issue with lasting consequences both for the individual and the health service (Crime and Corruption Commission 2020; Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse [RCIIRCSA] 2017). The importance that documentation plays in the patient journey was highlighted in the findings delivered in 2017 from the Royal Commission. It was discovered that children who suffered abuse took on average 23.9 years before coming forward to any authority (RCIIRCSA 2017).
The findings of the Royal Commission also reaffirmed the integral role that orderly documentation plays in the support of the patient journey when it has been created, stored, retained, and destroyed in accordance with prescribed guidelines (RCIIRCSA 2017). Due to the findings of the Royal Commission and the CCC, on 1 June 2018 the Queensland State Archives (QSA) placed a disposal freeze on all records connected to, or potentially connected to, a victim of child sexual abuse (Queensland Government 2021). The process of public record management had not been addressed since the Public Records Act 2002, and the freeze was lifted on 27 March 2020, marking the release of updated record management guidelines specifically dealing with the records of children (Queensland Government 2021).
In response to the findings of the Royal Commission, QSA developed processes to support victims of abuse. QSA created a definition of a vulnerable person to aid in the identification process, and new authorisations that related specifically to the retention of vulnerable persons’ documentation were added to the General Retention and Disposal Schedule (GRDS), which was issued on 3 December 2020 (Queensland State Archives 2020a). The following new authorisations are contained within Queensland’s GRDS:
- 1558 – Incidents, allegations, disclosures and investigations of abuse – vulnerable persons
- 1559 – Evidence of interactions and contact with vulnerable persons
- 1560 – Governance practices for proactive protection of vulnerable persons (Queensland State Archives 2020a).
Until recently, all medical records had been recorded on paper documentation, with minimal means to assess for eligibility against the criteria for destruction of the content contained within, beyond performing a manual search – issue one. Where clinical coding had been used to identify some criteria in medical records in the past, it may no longer be accurate by today’s standards due to the frequent changes and updates between the clinical classification editions and the resulting inconsistency in its application to clinical coding over long periods. This raises the potential for details to be missed – issue two. Considerable work had been done by healthcare providers to attempt to define and identify what a vulnerable person was, but a definitive list did not have 100% sign-off over all Queensland Health facilities – issue three. More issues were identified, and it was therefore deemed too large a task with too many obstacles to be completed within my 26-day project timeframe. Panic stations anyone?
A new approach – parallel records
In an effort to utilise the research I had already conducted, and to continue to support vulnerable patients, a review of the processes of parallel records involving creation, storage, retention and destruction of documentation was deemed an appropriate choice. I had not chosen this topic personally and therefore worried about my lack of personal interest in it. After all I had invested the better part of four months planning for my previous topic. I was invested in that topic. It took some time for me to realise that personal interest in a topic is not necessary, and in fact can get in the way of, a thorough analysis of procedures. I was confusing the need for a personal interest in the topic with what should have been a personal interest in the processes. It is a well-recognised fact that personal interest, and therefore emotion, in a topic can inform or even cloud a person’s judgement (Gino 2015). I was to perform a review and therefore needed to be unbiased in my approach. I needed to trust in the review process.
Now that I had reordered my thought processes the work could begin. In an effort to make medical record protection and management accessible to all, the Royal Commission acknowledges that all institutions and departments are different, with different capabilities and resources. With this in mind, three points, deemed imperative, but which could be achieved by an entity in a manner appropriate to their individual circumstances, were created:
- Documents are kept secured from unauthorised access
- Documents are held in conditions where they will not be damaged over time
- Documents can be identified and accessed when required (RCIIRCSA 2017).
Thorough and concise documentation is important for the support of all patient care, but it is vital for the support and protection of vulnerable persons (RCIIRCSA 2017). A parallel record works in collaboration with the main medical record to support the patient journey but is a completely separate entity (Queensland Health 2020). A parallel record can either be electronic or paper and acts as a repository for a variety of different types of information that all support the patient journey (Queensland Health 2020). If processes have been followed, a parallel record that is created, retained, stored, and destroyed in the defined manner (Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital [RBWH] 2020) plays an integral role in the support of vulnerable persons. With the aim of supporting the patient journey through the development of concise, effective, and streamlined documentation, the RBWH has developed the procedure 001062: Patient Clinical Records Management (Procedure 001062) (Queensland Health 2020).
In 2018, the Medical Records Department (MRD), did a review of the parallel records at the RBWH. All departments had the opportunity to interact with vulnerable persons, and it was discovered that some departments were following parallel record processes as instructed, and some departments had no processes being utilised. It is for these reasons that a review to ensure the preservation of documentation related to victims of abuse through appropriate creation, storage, retention, and disposal processes of all documentation including parallel records is of the utmost importance. Contained within Procedure 001062 are specific instructions for the development, storage, and retention of a patient’s parallel record.
Defining the review
For the project to review individual department’s parallel records, both the Royal Commission’s three steps and the RBWH’s Procedure 001062 were combined into summaries resulting in the development of an assessment criteria with four processes:
- An administrative alert must be created in the patient administration system – Hospital Based Corporate Information System
- A reflection / summary of activity of the parallel record must exist in the main clinical record – the integrated electronic medical record – for each encounter
- The physical parallel record must be stored in a secure and lockable location away from public access. Any electronic record must be stored with access and password protection
- Any movement of the parallel record requires tracking in the Patient Master Index and retention that adheres to Queensland’s GRDS.
Continuing from the work conducted by the MRD Manager in 2018, the Sexual Assault and Response Team (SART) was reviewed again and found to still be maintaining exemplary processes for creation, storage, retention, and destruction of parallel records. As a result, they were chosen to be used as the exemplar for comparison with other departments. The original project plan stated that the departments of Psychology, Valley Mental Health and Social Work were to be reviewed, but with further analysis they were found to no longer be using parallel records. Consequently, Neonatal Developmental Assessment Program (Neo Dap) and Audiology were chosen to be the departments for review. This change in the project plan was another reminder to me of how fluid the running of a project can be, how change is always a possibility. This time I had learnt how to handle change, therefore it didn’t matter that the departments had changed. I trusted in and applied the same four processes to the new departments.
Reviewing these departments aligns with the Royal Commission’s recommendations to support vulnerable persons through well maintained documentation, as their patients are covered in the vulnerable persons’ definition from QSA:
- A Child or Children; or
- An individual aged 18 years and above who is or may be unable to take care of themselves or is unable to protect themselves against harm or exploitation by reason of age, illness, trauma or disability, or any other reason. (Queensland State Archives 2020b).
SART’s patients have been harmed, making them vulnerable. Neo Dap’s patients are children, making them vulnerable and the Audiology Department’s patients have a disability, again making them vulnerable
When reviewing each department, contact was made by the MRD Manager, but both the MRD Manager and I attended the review. Assurance was given by the MRD Manager to each department, before any inspection had commenced, that I was bound by the same legislation as a Queensland Health employee when it came to maintaining patient security and privacy. The information gathered in these meetings formed the basis of the review. It was discovered in these reviews that parallel records act as repositories for the following different types of information at the RBWH: sensitive patient information and experiences; medical assessments with restricted copyright access; medical device calculations and notes; financial documents requiring quick access; and booklets not fit for scanning.
There were a number of significant differences between the three departments. SART had several hundred patients per year, Audiology had approximately 25 patients and Neo Dap was somewhere in-between. SART had their own filing compactus contained in a separate room, Audiology had two filing cabinets and Neo Dap had several filing cabinets and boxes spread over three separate areas. SART’s patient’s parallel records contained exceptionally sensitive and private information, Audiology’s parallel records were for candidate assessment, implant fitting and sale and service information. Neo Dap’s parallel records contained copyrighted tests; test results and booklets not fit for scanning. How to compare three different departments with three very different parallel records? Return to the processes, apply the processes. After the processes had been applied the results were compiled into a presentation for each department with an accompanying flowchart for future use.
The objectives of the project, Review of Parallel Records at the Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital (Review of Parallel Records) (Preston 2021), were to increase the awareness of the importance of parallel records at the RBWH and to educate the administration staff of their function and importance. These objectives were achieved after reviewing the parallel record processes of the three departments: SART; Neo Dap and Audiology and presenting the findings to them individually. In the process of reviewing the departments I discovered that some of the departments were not aware of the full extent of the importance of their parallel records. They knew they were important to their patients during current episodes of care but had not realised the benefit that proper record keeping practices brings to their patients in the future if they are ever identified as vulnerable. Therefore, it was incredibly important to have their review delivered in a presentation, not just to inform them that they were compliant, but also to reassure them that it was a job well done and worth doing well.
An integral part of the project’s success was not reserved solely for just trusting in the process. Regular consultation and feedback sessions with MRD Manager from the commencement of the project enabled the development of the project’s assessment processes. A quality management approach based on the method Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK) (Project Manager 2021) was employed to achieve a quality end product. The PMBOK approach focuses on: an Overall Quality Philosophy; Quality Assurance and Quality Control processes (Dixon 1987) that were facilitated and achieved through the regular consultation and feedback sessions convened with the MRD Manager. Through the process of regular check-in and feedback sessions the project was kept on track and on time. In moments of concern or worry, the MRD Manager was a wonderful support and provided a wealth of knowledge.
In conclusion
For a review to be successful it doesn’t have to bring about change. If a review finds all processes and procedures in alignment and being performed appropriately, then this is a success. This review found all parallel record procedures in all departments to be well developed and being performed in a methodical manner. The review also offered a morale booster to the departments involved. Many a comment was made as to how rewarding it was to have the assurance of a job well done. Further to this, the review provided success on a more personal level. It was a crash course exposure to the realities of running a project in the real world where changes will almost invariably need to be made and the ability to adjust and adapt to new circumstances is essential. These exposures and realities offered me a great opportunity to learn how to process and develop my own processes, processes that enabled me to deal with situations that arose whilst being in a safe and supported environment. How fortunate was I to have had this experience before going out into a brave new world? Immensely.
References
- Crime and Corruption Commission (2020) Operation Impala – Report on misuse of confidential information in the Queensland public sector. Report, Crime and Corruption Commission, Brisbane, February. Available at: https://www.ccc.qld.gov.au/publications/operation-impala-report-misuse-confidential-information-queensland-public-sector (accessed 1 April 2022).
- Dixon W (1987) Quality Management. PM Network 1(3): 15–18.
- Gino F (2015) Don’t Let Emotions Screw Up Your Decisions. Available at: https://hbr.org/2015/05/dont-let-emotions-screw-up-your-decisions#:~:text=Emotions%20can%20cloud%20our%20judgment,and%20affect%20another%2C%20unrelated%20situation (accessed 1 April 2022).
- Project Manager (2021) What is project management? Available at: https://www.projectmanager.com/project-management (accessed 1 April 2022).
- Preston H (2021) Review of Parallel Records at the Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital [Unpublished report, PUB373]. Queensland University of Technology.
- Queensland Health (Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital, Health Information Services) (2020) 001062: Patient Clinical Records Management.
- Queensland Government (2021) Disposal freezes for records. Available at: https://www.forgov.qld.gov.au/disposal-freezes-for-records#previous (accessed 1 April 2022).
- Queensland State Archives (2020a) General Retention and Disposal Schedule (GRDS). Available at: https://www.forgov.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0026/188270/general-retention-and-disposal-schedule-grds.pdf (accessed 1 April 2022).
- Queensland State Archives (2020b) Guideline on creating and keeping records for the proactive protection of vulnerable persons. Available at: https://www.forgov.qld.gov.au/information-and-communication-technology/recordkeeping-and-information-management/recordkeeping/manage-specific-record-types-and-activities/records-relating-to-vulnerable-persons (accessed 1 April 2022).
- Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse (2017) Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse (Final report). Report, Attorney-General’s Department, Barton, December. Available at: https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/final-report (accessed 1 April 2022).
Authors
Helen Preston
Bachelor of Health Information Management Student; Queensland University of Technology
PO Box 1481
Kenmore QLD 4069
Email: hl.preston@connect.qut.edu.au

