groupJennie Shepheard, Andrea Groom

menu_bookVolume 11 Number 1

collections_bookmarkReports

lockMember Access

printPrint Article


This guest editorial was published in the Health Information Management Journal Virtual The Role of Health Classifications in Health Information Management (Volume 49, Issue 2-3, May-September 2020). It can be accessed at https://journals.sagepub.com/page/him/collections/healthclassifications.

Formal health classifications facilitate the collection of significant quantities of health data in the form of clinical codes. The International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, Tenth Revision, Australian Modification (ICD-10-AM) is used in Australia (and many countries around the world) primarily to report information about admitted patients’ diagnoses while the treatment provided to the patient is reported using the Australian Classification of Health Interventions. The Australian Refined Diagnosis Related Groups use these clinical codes to group patients into like categories and represent another important health classification that is widely used by managers of health information in government departments, hospitals and health funds. In Australia, the Independent Hospital Pricing Authority is responsible for managing these classifications (IHPA, 2019). Health information managers (HIMs) and clinical coders (CCs) are responsible for the clinical coding of admitted patient records, thereby creating the bulk of these health data. The data are reported to state and federal government departments from where they are made available for use by multiple stakeholders, such as researchers, program managers and funding model developers. Within individual hospitals, researchers, funding managers and other stakeholders will also access these data to inform their work.

A virtual special issue on The Role of Health Classifications in Health Information Management has brought together several articles, grouped according to recurring themes (as shown in Box 1), which demonstrate the diversity of work with these major classifications. Campbell and Giadresco (2020) explored the available literature on computer-assisted clinical coding (CAC) and concluded that improved data quality is the outcome and that HIMs and CCs should view this as an opportunity for growth. They explained that CAC automates the clinical coding process and will require HIMs and CCs to develop their skills to enable them to function effectively in an integrated electronic system where classifications and terminologies are likely to be linked. Hoyle (2019: 48) discussed the challenges for HIMs in an environment where machine enabled coding may be the reality but also made the point that clinical coding and expertise in classification are “core skills” of the health information management profession.

Box 1. Articles selected for inclusion in the Virtual Special Issue on the Role of Health Classifications in Health
Information Management have been grouped according to recurring themes identified by the Guest Editors:

Clinical documentation

Clinical documentation refers to the source documents from which coded data are produced using the classifications.

  • Alonso V, Santos JV, Pinto M, et al. (2020) Health records as the basis of clinical coding: Is the quality adequate? A qualitative study of medical coders’ perceptions. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 28–37.
  • Hay P, Wilton K, Barker J, et al. (2020) The importance of clinical documentation improvement for Australian hospitals. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 69–73.
  • Rowlands S, Coverdale S and Callen J (2016) Documentation of clinical care in hospital patients’ medical records: a qualitative study of medical students’ perspectives on clinical documentation education. Health Information Management Journal 45(3): 99–106.
  • Shepheard J (2018) What do we really want from clinical documentation improvement programs? Health Information Management Journal 47(1): 3–5.
  • Zhandire T, Gqaleni N, Ngcobo M, et al. (2020) Knowledge and documentation of patient health information among traditional health practitioners in urban and peri-urban in Durban, Kwa-Zulu-Natal Province, South Africa. Health Information Management Journal. Epub ahead of print 31 December 2019. DOI: 10.1177/1833358319890475

Complexities in health classification and clinical coding

(i) Interdependencies inherent in the nature of the work

Classification systems and clinical coding practices are interdependent. Combining their professional knowledge and expertise in these two related areas, clinical coders contribute significantly to the body of administrative data held by healthcare systems around the world.

  • Cappetta K, Lago L, Potter J, et al. (2020). Under-coding of dementia and other conditions indicates scope for improved patient
  • management: A longitudinal retrospective study of dementia patients in Australia. Health Information Management Journal. Epub ahead of print 23 January 2020. DOI: 10.1177/1833358319897928
  • Handley JD and Emsley HC (2020) Validation of ICD-10 codes shows intracranial venous thrombosis incidence to be higher than previously reported. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 58–61.
  • Nguyen TQ, Simpson PM, Braaf SC, et al. (2019) Level of agreement between medical record and ICD-10-AM coding of mental health, alcohol and drug conditions in trauma patients. Health Information Management Journal 48(3): 127–134.
  • Phillips W, Doley J and Boi K (2020) Malnutrition definitions in clinical practice: to be E43 or not to be? Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 74–79.
  • Sveticic J, Stapelberg NCJ and Turner K (2020) Suicidal and self-harm presentations to Emergency Departments: the challenges of identification through diagnostic codes and presenting complaints. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 38–46.
  • Trinh LTT, Achat H and Assareh H (2017) Use of routinely collected data in reporting falls in hospitals in a local health district in New South Wales, Australia. Health Information Management Journal 46(1): 15–22.
  • Trinh LTT, Achat H, Loh SM, et al. (2018) Validity of routinely collected data in identifying hip fractures at a major tertiary hospital in Australia. Health Information Management Journal 47(1): 38–45.

(ii) Situational and environmental complexities

Health information managers and clinical coders use the classifications to produce clinically coded data. They work in complex environments with emerging technologies and competing demands on their expertise.

  • Campbell S and Giadresco K (2020) Computer-assisted clinical coding: a narrative review of the literature on its benefits, limitations, implementation and impact on clinical coding professionals. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 5–18.
  • Paoin W, Yuenyongsuwan M, Yokobori Y, et al. (2018) Development of the ICD-10 simplified version and field test. Health Information Management Journal 47(2): 77–84.
  • Reid B, Ridout L and O’Connor P (2017a) Best practice in the management of clinical coding services: insights from a project in the Republic of Ireland, Part 1. Health Information Management Journal 46(2): 69–77.
  • Reid B, Ridout L and O’Connor P (2017b) Best practice in the management of clinical coding services: insights from a project in the Republic of Ireland, Part 2. Health Information Management Journal 46(3): 105–112.

Impact of classification and clinical coding on various stakeholders

The accuracy and completeness of the coded data impact on the reliability of research, with researchers having to rely on the work of clinical coders and the currency of the classifications to carry out their work.

  • Doktorchik C, Lu M, Quan H, et al. (2020) A qualitative evaluation of clinically coded data quality from health information manager perspectives. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 19–27.
  • Murray J, Pfeiffer R and Scholten I (2017) Coding of significant comorbidities and complications for stroke in rehabilitation. Health Information Management Journal 46(3): 134–139.
  • Resslar MA, Ivanitskaya LV, Perez MA, et al. (2019) Sources of variability in hospital administrative data: clinical coding of postoperative ileus. Health Information Management Journal 48(2): 101–108.
  • Safdari R, Rezaeizadeh H, Arji G, et al. (2019) The necessity to develop a national classification system for Iranian traditional medicine. Health Information Management Journal. Epub ahead of print 9 September 2019. DOI: 10.1177/1833358319872820

The classifications provide accessible and inexpensive information in the administrative databases that can be used to monitor patient safety.

  • Michel JL, Nghiem HS and Jackson TJ (2009) Using ICD-10-AM codes to characterise hospital-acquired complications. Health Information Management Journal 38(3): 18–25.
  • Shepheard J, Lapiz E, Read C, et al. (2019) Reconciling hospital acquired complications and CHADx+ in Victorian coded hospital data. Health Information Management Journal 48(2): 76–86.

Disease and intervention classifications are used to create diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) in many countries around the world. These DRGs are used extensively in acute inpatient funding models.

  • Kim S, Jung C, Yon J, et al. (2020) A review of the complexity adjustment in the Korean Diagnosis-Related Group (KDRG).
    Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 62–68.
  • Souza J, Santos JV, Canedo VB, et al. (2020) Importance of coding co-morbidities for APR-DRG assignment: focus on cardiovascular and respiratory diseases. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 47–57.

Information technology architecture determines the accessibility of health data and can go beyond that required for legislated reporting.

  • Kumar M, Mostafa J and Ramaswamy R (2018) Federated health information architecture: enabling healthcare providers and policymakers to use data for decision-making. Health Information Management Journal 47(2): 85–93.

Regardless of the way clinical coding is undertaken, good documentation is essential to support the use of the classifications. The clinical documentation must use language that can be translated into clinical codes (Rowlands et al., 2016). Hay et al. (2020: 69) discussed the role of clinical documentation improvement (CDI) specialists in ensuring that documentation is able to be translated into the clinical codes that are “one of the building blocks of reporting for public and private hospitals.” Shepheard (2018) made the point that CDI programs must be adequately resourced and must focus on identifying the clinical truth to support quality clinical coding and that HIMs and CCs are well placed to fulfil these roles. Zhandire et al. (2020) highlighted the deficiency in documentation of African traditional medicine practice, making good health information difficult, if not impossible, to obtain.

Researchers rely on the coded data for much of their work and are therefore interested in the integrity of the data and the relevance of the classifications to their sphere of interest. Several articles in this Virtual Special Issue report on studies to reconcile the information in the medical record or in other databases with the coded data held in admitted patient datasets (Handley and Emsley, 2020; Murray et al., 2017; Nguyen et al., 2019; Sveticic et al., 2020; Trinh et al., 2017, 2018). They identify a range of issues associated with the coded data, including that in some cases conditions are not being coded and in others that clinical codes do not provide the specificity needed for good research. Cappetta et al. (2020) reported on a study where the under-coding of dementia highlighted opportunities to improve identification and management of dementia. Resslar et al. (2019: 102) reported on several studies that challenge “the belief that administrative data can be compared across hospitals” (Kaafaran et al., 2011; Koch et al., 2012; Parker et al., 2006; Scott and Ward, 2006) and argued that “inaccurate information is currently used for purposes never intended by ICD-9-CM designers.” Phillips et al. (2019) in their discussion of the documentation and coding of malnutrition highlight the challenges that occur when the classification does not reflect current clinical terminology and encourage documentation specialists to work to address this. Alonso et al. (2020: 32) conducted focus groups to identify the factors in the medical records that adversely impact on accurate and useful classification outcomes. These Portuguese authors argued that while ‘health records and their quality have great importance, not only for the medical coding activity but also for further uses of the databases generated by the coded data’ several problems exist in relation to documentation in the medical record and solutions are not being found.

The ICD-10-AM classification has been used by Michel et al. (2009: 18) to create the Classification of Hospital Acquired Diagnoses (CHADx), which they described as “designed to allow hospitals to monitor their complication rates month-to-month using a standard method.” Shepheard et al. (2019) used this secondary classification to compare complication rates between CHADx and the rates identified using the Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care’s (ACSQHC, 2019a) Hospital Acquired Complications (HACs) algorithms. In addition to the HACs, the ACSQHC has also used the classification to produce a set of Core Hospital Based Outcome Indicators for mortality (ACSQHC, 2019b).

Diagnosis Related Groups (DRGs), developed from the analysis of the clinical codes in administrative databases, are one of the most high-profile uses of clinically coded data. Souza et al. (2020: 47) discussed the importance of coding co-morbidities to the severity of illness (SOI) levels in the All Patient-Refined-DRG classification. They concluded that “comprehensive reporting of pre-existing or newly acquired co-morbidities should be encouraged in hospitals as they have an important influence on SOI assignment and thus on hospital funding.” Kim et al. (2020), in their review of the complexity adjustment of Korean DRGs, also highlighted the need for high-quality clinical coding to support the complexity algorithms in DRGs. Clearly the integrity and quality of the data is of utmost importance, not only to the end users of the data but to all stakeholders, including patients, who may be impacted by the work of researchers and other health professionals. Good classification practices are integral to high-quality data. Kilkenny and Robinson (2018: 103) wrote about the importance of data integrity in their editorial titled Garbage in, garbage out. They made the point that “the information collected needs to be highly accurate otherwise data analytics, applications or business process will be unreliable.” Of course, the data must be available in order to be valuable, and Kumar et al. (2018: 85) emphasised the importance of a health information architecture that serves “the diverse information needs of various stakeholders.” A solution for this has been developed by the World Health Organization (WHO) Family of International Classifications Asia-Pacific Network for use in developing countries as an introductory tool until they have systems to support full ICD-10 and subsequently ICD-11 coding. Safdari et al. (2020) discussed the developments in Iran and by the WHO to incorporate traditional medicine data into existing data collections.

Importantly the health information management and clinical coding workforces must not be overlooked. Paoin (2018: 77) explained that health classification can be complicated and “clinical coding processes are complex.” Challenges experienced by this workforce are described by Doktorchik et al. (2020), who identified the common barriers to clinical coding quality, which in addition to resourcing and education issues include issues with incomplete and unorganised chart documentation. Rowlands et al. (2016) explained that the clinicians who are responsible for the documentation in the medical record that underpins the coded data are not necessarily educated about how to document effectively for good patient care and the production of good data for multiple downstream uses. Reid et al. (2017a, 2017b) in their two part article about Best Practice in the Management of Clinical Coding Services: Insights from a Project in the Republic of Ireland also described issues with poor documentation, lack of clinician involvement with data quality and the need to support the clinical coding workforce in a way that makes them feel valued. A series of articles published by Dimitropoulos et al. (2019a, 2019b, 2019c) in the Health Information Management Association of Australia’s (HIMAA) profession practice journal, HIM-Interchange, reported on findings from a clinical coding workforce survey conducted by the National Centre for Classification in Health (NCCH) and a workshop conducted by the NCCH at the 35th HIMAA and NCCH National Conference. These articles described a workforce struggling with the increasing demands of producing the coded data that is so vital to the many stakeholders represented in this Virtual Special Issue. Resslar et al. (2019: 107) explored the question of the validity of clinical codes in hospital administrative data through a recoding exercise of post-operative ileus and concluded that “the issues shown in this study are the same issues that clinical coders all over the world face – lack of clear definitions, variable interpretation of existing guidelines, and multiple sources of advice.”

The issues discussed by the authors of papers in the Virtual Special Issue highlight the health classifications’ many uses, interdependencies between users, need for accuracy, and accessibility, and the complexity of the classification work undertaken by CCs and HIMs. All of us involved in health information management must recognise the importance of classifications to the integrity of the coded data, ensuring stakeholder confidence in the data and the ability of the classifications to deliver the information users need. As Hoyle (2019: 50) pointed out, the health information management profession must “take the initiative by starting conversations, forging partnerships, researching, writing, publishing and making its knowledge and insights not only known but useful.”

Declaration of conflicting interests

The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.


References

  • Alonso V, Santos JV, Pinto M, et al. (2020) Health records as the basis of clinical coding: Is the quality adequate? A qualitative study of medical coders’ perceptions. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 28–37.
  • Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care (ACSQHC) (2019a) Hospital-acquired complications. Available at: https://www.safetyandquality.gov.au/publicationsand-resources/resource-library/hospital-acquired-complications-hacs-list-specifications-version-30 (accessed 8 December 2019).
  • Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care (ACSQHC) (2019b) National core, hospital-based outcome indicators. Available at: https://www.safetyandquality.gov.au/publications-and-resources/resource-library/national-corehospital-based-outcome-indicator-specification (accessed 26November 2019).
  • Campbell S and Giadresco K (2020) Computer-assisted clinical coding: a narrative review of the literature on its benefits, limitations, implementation and impact on clinical coding professionals. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 5–18.
  • Cappetta K, Lago L, Potter J, et al. (2020) Under-coding of dementia and other conditions indicates scope for improved patient management: A longitudinal retrospective study of dementia patients in Australia. Health Information Management Journal. Epub ahead of print 23 January 2020. DOI: 10.1177/1833358319897928
  • Dimitropoulos V, Lean N, Butler-Henderson K, et al. (2019a) Supporting clinical coders: future proofing the integrity of our clinical coded data. HIM-Interchange 9(1): 17–24.
  • Dimitropoulos V, Lean N, Butler-Henderson K, et al. (2019b) Supporting clinical coders: understanding the challenges. HIM-Interchange 9(2): 4–17.
  • Dimitropoulos V, Lean N, Butler-Henderson K, et al. (2019c) Supporting clinical coders: understanding the value proposition. HIM-Interchange 9(3): 8–11.
  • Doktorchik C, Lu M, Quan H, et al. (2020) A qualitative evaluation of clinically coded data quality from health information manager perspectives. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 19–27.
  • Handley JD and Emsley HC (2020) Validation of ICD-10 codes shows intracranial venous thrombosis incidence to be higher than previously reported. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 58–61.
  • Hay P, Wilton K, Barker J, et al. (2020) The importance of clinical documentation improvement for Australian hospitals. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 69–73.
  • Hoyle P (2019) Health information is central to changes in healthcare: a clinician’s view. Health Information Management Journal 48(1): 48–51.
  • Independent Hospital Pricing Authority (IHPA) (2019) Admitted acute care classifications. Available at: https://www.ihpa.gov.au/what-we-do/admitted-acute-care (accessed 8 December 2019).
  • Kaafarani H, Borzecki AM, Itani KM, et al. (2011) Validity of selected patient safety indicators: opportunities and concerns. Journal of the American College of Surgeons 212(6): 924–934.
  • Kilkenny MF and Robinson KM (2018) Data quality: “Garbage in–garbage out.” Health Information Management Journal 47(3): 103–105.
  • Kim S, Jung C, Yon J, et al. (2020) A review of the complexity adjustment in the Korean Diagnosis-Related Group (KDRG). Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 62–68.
  • Koch CG, Li L, Hixson E, et al. (2012) What are the real rates of postoperative complications: elucidating inconsistencies between administrative and clinical data sources. Journal of the American College of Surgeons 214(5): 798–805.
  • Kumar M, Mostafa J and Ramaswamy R (2018) Federated health information architecture: enabling healthcare providers and policymakers to use data for decision-making. Health Information Management Journal 47(2): 85–93.
  • Michel JL, Nghiem HS and Jackson TJ (2009) Using ICD-10-AM codes to characterise hospital-acquired complications. Health Information Management Journal 38(3): 18–25.
  • Murray J, Pfeiffer R and Scholten I (2017) Coding of significant comorbidities and complications for stroke in rehabilitation. Health Information Management Journal 46(3): 134–139.
  • Nguyen TQ, Simpson PM, Braaf SC, et al. (2019) Level of agreement between medical record and ICD-10-AM coding of mental health, alcohol and drug conditions in trauma patients. Health Information Management Journal 48(3):127–134.
  • Paoin W, Yuenyongsuwan M, Yokobori Y, et al. (2018) Development of the ICD-10 simplified version and field test. Health Information Management Journal 47(2): 77–84.
  • Parker JP, Zhongmin L, Damberg CL, et al. (2006) Administrative versus clinical data for coronary artery bypass graft surgery report cards: the view from California. Medical Care 44(7): 687–695.
  • Phillips W, Doley J and Boi K (2019) Malnutrition definitions in clinical practice: to be E43 or not to be? Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 74–79.
  • Reid B, Ridout L and O’Connor P (2017a) Best practice in the management of clinical coding services: insights from a project in the Republic of Ireland, Part 1. Health Information Management Journal 46(2): 69–77.
  • Reid B, Ridout L and O’Connor P (2017b) Best practice in the management of clinical coding services: insights from a project in the Republic of Ireland, Part 2. Health Information Management Journal 46(3): 105–112.
  • Resslar MA, Ivanitskaya LV, Perez MA, et al. (2019) Sources of variability in hospital administrative data: clinical coding of postoperative ileus. Health Information Management Journal 48(2): 101–108.
  • Rowlands S, Coverdale S and Callen J (2016) Documentation of clinical care in hospital patients’ medical records: a qualitative study of medical students’ perspectives on clinical documentation education. Health Information Management Journal 45(3): 99–106.
  • Safdari R, Rezaeizadeh H, Arji G, et al. (2019) The necessity to develop a national classification system for Iranian traditional medicine. Health Information Management Journal. Epub ahead of print 9 September 2019. DOI: 10.1177/1833358319872820.
  • Scott IA and Ward M (2006) Public reporting of hospital outcomes based on administrative data: risks and opportunities. Medical Journal of Australia 184(11): 571–575.
  • Shepheard J (2018) What do we really want from clinical documentation improvement programs? Health Information Management Journal 47(1): 3–5.
  • Shepheard J, Lapiz E, Read C, et al. (2019) Reconciling hospital acquired complications and CHADx+ in Victorian coded hospital data. Health Information Management Journal 48(2): 76–86.
  • Souza J, Santos JV, Canedo VB, et al. (2020) Importance of coding co-morbidities for APR-DRG assignment: focus on cardiovascular and respiratory diseases. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 47–57.
  • Sveticic J, Stapelberg NCJ and Turner K (2020) Suicidal and self harm presentations to Emergency Departments: the challenges of identification through diagnostic codes and presenting complaints. Health Information Management Journal 49(1): 38–46.
  • Trinh LTT, Achat H and Assareh H (2017) Use of routinely collected data in reporting falls in hospitals in a local health district in New South Wales, Australia. Health Information Management Journal 46(1): 15–22.
  • Trinh LTT, Achat H, Loh SM, et al. (2018) Validity of routinely collected data in identifying hip fractures at a major tertiary hospital in Australia. Health Information Management Journal 47(1): 38–45.
  • Zhandire T, Gqaleni N, Ngcobo M, et al. (2020) Knowledge and documentation of patient health information among traditional health practitioners in urban and peri-urban in Durban, Kwa-Zulu-Natal Province, South Africa. Health Information Management Journal. Epub ahead of print 31 December 2019.DOI: 10.1177/1833358319890475

Authors

Jennie Shepheard, RMRL, GDipHlthAdmin, CertHlthEco, MPH
Shepheard Health Management Consultants, Australia    

Andrea Groom, AssDip(MRA), AdvDip(BusMgt)
Health Information Consultant/ Director
Clinical Coding Services Pty Ltd, Australia